Fukushima Japan Floating windmills offer hope of ending nuclear reliance

Floating windmills offer hope of ending nuclear reliance
By CHISAKI WATANABE
Wednesday, April 4, 2012
Bloomberg


A consortium backed by the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry is preparing to bolt turbines onto barges and build the world's largest commercial power plant using floating windmills off Fukushima Prefecture, tackling the engineering challenges of an unproven technology to cut reliance on nuclear power.


http://www.facebook.com/nuclearfree
http://www.facebook.com/renewableenergy1



Marubeni Corp., Mitsubishi Heavy Industries Ltd. and Nippon Steel Corp. are among the developers erecting the 16-megawatt pilot plant. The project may be expanded to 1,000 megawatts, METI said, bigger than any wind farm fixed to the seabed or on land.


"Japan is surrounded by deep oceans, and this poses challenges to offshore wind turbines that are attached to the bottom of the sea," senior vice environment minister Katsuhiko Yokomitsu said last month. "We are eager for floating offshore wind to become a viable technology."


The world's third-largest economy is struggling to diversify its energy mix after last year's earthquake and tsunami crippled Tokyo Electric Power Co.'s Fukushima No. 1 nuclear power plant. A few countries — including Britain, the U.S. and South Korea — are testing windmills that float, a technology far more expensive than most fossil-fuel or renewable energies.


Mitsubishi Heavy Industries and its partners are positioning themselves for future contracts to develop gear that so far isn't used in commercial electricity production.


Capital expenditure is about $1.7 million a megawatt for an onshore wind project and $5.5 million a megawatt for offshore, according to Bloomberg New Energy Finance. Statoil ASA has the largest floating project currently, a 2.3-megawatt "Hywind" turbine off the coast of Norway, which cost $29 million a megawatt, according estimates by Fraser Johnston, an offshore wind analyst for the agency in London, based on company data.


"Hywind is a 10-year project from the drawing board in 2001 to when we were done with the demo period last year," Morten Eek, a Statoil spokesman, said. "In a commercial phase, the costs will be significantly lower based on the experience from the demo project."


Statoil is currently considering two test parks off Scotland and the U.S. with three to five windmills each, potentially by 2016.


Japan "certainly has excellent offshore wind resources and huge potential to develop this sector," said Justin Wu, lead wind analyst for New Energy Finance in Hong Kong. "But offshore wind is significantly more expensive than onshore wind at the moment."


Japan, whose geography and earthquake risk have long shaped its economy, is lagging behind developed nations, including the United States, Germany and Spain, in wind energy. Wind supplied just 0.4 percent of Japan's electricity demand in 2010, according to the International Energy Agency Wind 2010 Annual Report.


Ranking as the world's fifth-largest carbon emitter, Japan is trying to elevate its wind-energy capacity from 2,500 megawatts, the 13th-highest among all nations, according to the Global Wind Energy Council.


Land-based wind energy development is limited by Japan's mountains, making offshore developments more viable. The depths of the oceans nearby creates a bigger potential for floating turbine technology, which is still in its infancy compared with the more conventional method of deploying fixed versions of the machines.


The turbines are mounted on a floating structure that allows them to generate electricity in water depths where bottom-mounted towers cannot be erected easily. The country aims to develop the floating offshore wind turbines for commercialization by March 2017.


The biggest challenge in erecting floating turbines offshore is ensuring the buoyancy mechanisms are stable, and getting fixed lines to the seabed, which can be extended to depths of 200 meters.


A so-called feed-in tariff program due to start in July that guarantees above market rates for clean energy including solar, wind and geothermal could boost the development of wind energy, analysts say.


"We believe Japan's sluggish wind market will experience a kick-start under the FIT," CLSA Asia-Pacific Markets analysts Penn Bowers and Dean Enjo said in a Feb. 20 report. "Historically, in countries that have implemented FIT schemes it is wind, not solar, that grows the most," it said, citing Germany and China as examples.


Japan's production of wind turbines and parts and maintenance services is forecast to grow from an estimated ¥300 billion a year currently to ¥500 billion in 2030, according to the Japan Wind Power Association.


The industry group has set a wind-power installation target of 50,000 megawatts by March 2051, including 17,500 megawatts and 7,500 megawatts in floating and fixed offshore wind respectively. That compares with the 49,000 megawatts of nuclear power, which is being debated by the government after the triple-meltdown at the Fukushima No. 1 plant. The JWPA estimates Japan's potential for wind is 144,000 megawatts for onshore and 608,000 megawatts for offshore.


The government hasn't determined what rates they will earn. A delay in price setting may deter investments and put wind power at a disadvantage compared with solar because it takes longer to build a wind farm.


A new regulation due to take effect in October could also delay wind projects. Wind will be added to a list of power plants such as nuclear and thermal that will be subjected to environmental impact assessments to address concerns about noise and birds.


Such surveys can take as many as four years and cost developers an additional ¥100 million for a plant with about 10 turbines, according to Tetsuro Nagata, president of the wind association.


That also means wind developers may fail to take advantage of the first three years when feed-in tariffs are expected to be higher, he said in an interview.


"Even though the government may set high tariff prices, developers will be left unable to do anything" while conducting an assessment, Nagata said. "That is not fair."


The government is considering measures to simplify the process, said Kenji Kamita, an official at the Environment Ministry who oversees assessment of projects.


To increase wind capacity in a mountainous country, Japan is looking offshore, where wind speeds are faster and more stable.


"Japan has a weak position in onshore wind," METI's task force on new energy industries said in a report released March 12. "But the floating offshore technology is not yet established so this is an area we can aim for a comeback."


The environment ministry plans to set up a 2-megawatt floating offshore turbine in Nagasaki by June 2013. The project is being developed by Toda Corp. and Fuji Heavy Industries Ltd.


The Fukushima pilot project will have three floating turbines installed by March 2016 with plans to eventually expand the capacity to 1,000 megawatts in the region, according to METI. It has set aside ¥12.5 billion as the ceiling to fund the initial stages of the study.


METI has also been steadily increasing funding for offshore wind research and development, mainly for fixed turbines, from ¥200 million in 2008 to ¥5.2 billion this year.


For offshore wind farms, cooperation with local fishing industries is also key, said Chuichi Arakawa, a professor at the University of Tokyo who studies wind power.


"It all begins with having thorough discussions with local partners," he said.